Rest & Soap transactional capability -


in 1 interview, interviewer asked, transactional capability,out of soap , rest having transactional capabilities?

could please explain me in simple way.

thanks in advance,

had come across these references when ran similar questions. hope helps.

  • from http://spf13.com/post/soap-vs-rest

    ws-atomictransaction need acid transactions on service, you’re going need soap. while rest supports transactions, isn’t comprehensive , isn’t acid compliant. fortunately acid transactions never make sense on internet. rest limited http can’t provide two-phase commit across distributed transactional resources, soap can. internet apps don’t need level of transactional reliability, enterprise apps do.

  • from https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/magazine/dd942839.aspx

    what transactions?

    here area in soap , ws-* have explicit support "advanced" feature , rest has none. ws-atomic transactions supports distributed, two-phase commit transactional semantics on soap-based services. rest has no support distributed transactions. speaking, if want transactions in restful system, create new resource. (creating new resource whenever run problem restful system solves problems.) can have resource called transaction. when client needs transactional (such transferring money between 2 bank accounts), client creates transaction resource specifies correct resources affected (in example, 2 bank accounts) doing post transaction factory uri. client can perform updates sending put transaction uri , close transaction sending delete uri.

    this, of course, requires amount of hand-coding , explicit control on system, whereas ws-atomic transactions system more automatic because (in case of windows communication foundation) tied runtime's plumbing.

    if system absolutely needs atomic transactional semantics across diverse systems, ws-atomic transactions way go. using distributed transactions in way may or may not smart because increases coupling between 2 systems , creates potential problems if aren't controlling code on both ends. important thing use right tool right job (once you've figure out right job is). in defense of rest, think fair given today's distributed, service-oriented architectures, coupling 2 endpoints tightly using distributed transaction may not best design. on other hand, situations call type of functionality, , if need it, use soap , ws-atomic transactions.


-

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

OpenCV OpenCL: Convert Mat to Bitmap in JNI Layer for Android -

there several posts converting mat bitmap using utils.mattobitmap() function. i'm assuming function can called in java layer after importing utils class. i want transfer data memory address pointed uint32_t* bmpcontent; in code below. jniexport void jnicall java_com_nod_nodcv_nodcvactivity_runfilter( jnienv *env, jclass clazz, jobject outbmp, jbytearray indata, jint width, jint height, jint choice, jint filter) { int outsz = width*height; int insz = outsz + outsz/2; androidbitmapinfo bmpinfo; if (androidbitmap_getinfo(env, outbmp, &bmpinfo) < 0) { throwjavaexception(env,"gaussianblur","error retrieving bitmap meta data"); return; } if (bmpinfo.format != android_bitmap_format_rgba_8888) { throwjavaexception(env,"gaussianblur","expecting rgba_8888 format"); return; } uint32_t* bmpcontent; if (androidbitmap_lockpixels(env, outbmp,(void**)&bmpcontent)...
Read more

android - org.xmlpull.v1.XmlPullParserException: expected: START_TAG {http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/}Envelope -

i trying hit soap api in application login purpose , getting above mentioned error , can 1 tell me going wrong , first time soap apis. here code hit soap :- vector<object> args = new vector<object>(); hashtable<string, object> hashtable = new hashtable<string, object>(); hashtable.put("email", "mss.siddhart28@gmail.com"); hashtable.put("password", "siddharth"); args.add(hashtable); soapserializationenvelope envelope = new soapserializationenvelope( soapenvelope.ver11); envelope.dotnet = true; envelope.xsd = soapserializationenvelope.xsd; envelope.enc = soapserializationenvelope.enc; (new marshalhashtable()).register(envelope); httptransportse androidhttptransport = new httptransportse( "http://tempuri.org/", 15000); androidhttptransport.debug = true; string result = ""; try { soapobject request = new soapobject("http:...
Read more

python - How to remove the Xframe Options header in django? -

i have made page has iframe . inside iframe want show multiple different links article facebook, or news, or youtube video or other possible url. but, due xframe header, unable so. referred following link: https://docs.djangoproject.com/en/1.8/ref/clickjacking/ , django xframeoptionsmiddleware (x-frame-options) - allow iframe client ip but didn't help. my settings.py file's middleware_classes is: middleware_classes = ( 'django.contrib.sessions.middleware.sessionmiddleware', 'django.middleware.common.commonmiddleware', 'django.middleware.csrf.csrfviewmiddleware', 'django.contrib.auth.middleware.authenticationmiddleware', 'django.contrib.auth.middleware.sessionauthenticationmiddleware', 'django.contrib.messages.middleware.messagemiddleware', 'django.middleware.clickjacking.xframeoptionsmiddleware', ) from http://django-secure.readthedocs.org/en/latest/middleware.html , found using ...
Read more